Front View of Thomas House

Ward-Thomas Museum

Ohio Association of Historical Societies and Museums

Five images of buildings and grounds

Pete's Dairy

Ward — Thomas Museum
Home of the Niles Historical Society
503 Brown Street Niles, Ohio 44446

Return to the Homepage

Click on any photograph to view a larger image.


Email Us

Phone: 330.544.2143
Mail: PO Box 368 Niles, Ohio 44446

Individual Membership: $20.00
Family Membership: $30.00
Patron Membership: $50.00
Business Membership: $100.00
Lifetime Membership: $500.00
Corporate Membership:
Call 330.544.2143

Do you love the history of Niles, Ohio and want to preserve that history and memories of events for future generations?

Click here to donate:

As a 501(c)3 non-profit organization, your donation is tax deductible. When you click on the Donate Button, you will be taken to a secure Website where your donation will entered and a receipt generated.






(Pete) George Harold McMurray

(Pete) George Harold McMurray.

Gary Mercer by the front door of Pete's Dairy, 1962

Gary Mercer by the front door of Pete's Dairy, 1962.

Pete's Dairy is no longer, only the lot remains by the alleyway that separates Lincoln and Washinton Avenues on Pearl Street.Pete's Dairy is no longer, only the lot remains by the alleyway that separates Lincoln and Washinton Avenues on Pearl Street.

Gone are the kids from the neighborhood that would sit on the curb in front of the store slurping on their dripping popsicles on a hot summer day.

Below are sample advertisements:

sample advertisements

sample advertisements

Pete’s Dairy

Information: Jay McMurray
There are so many great memories growing up in Niles as a ‘Baby Boomer’ but the neighborhood store stands out the most. Each neighborhood had a little store where your mother would send you to pick up a loaf of bread, sandwich meat, or some treat for your school lunch like Twinkies or Hostess cupcakes filled with crème and topped with chocolate fudge frosting.

Joan Miles, “We lived on the corner of Lafayette and Hughes. There were several of those ‘Mom and Pop’ stores in our neighborhood. I remember McAllister’s on Vienna Avenue, Cartwright’s by the old Lincoln School, and Smith’s was another small store by Lincoln School.” Elizabeth Bridgen, “I lived on Southside and there was a store just like Pete’s Dairy called Partridges and I worked there every evening from 5-9 p.m. and 8-4 on Saturday. I was the only one working evenings, lock up and walk home around the corner. No fear. Those were the days. Fun!”

Pete’s Dairy was located on Pearl Street between Lincoln and Washington Avenues with an alley on the left side of the store. The outside was brown fiber shingles with a front entrance of a single door. Joe Dugan remembers, “Back in the day we walked to Pete’s on our lunch break from Washington Jr. High. Our nutritious lunch consisted of a cupcake, bag of chips and a soda for a whopping 35 cents total-sweet memories”.

“(Pete) George Harold McMurray Born July 1, 1916 Niles Ohio on Bentley Avenue. Pete grew up on Bentley Avenue, moved to Washington Avenue, then to Lincoln Avenue, then to Bentley and in 1955 back to 723 Lincoln Avenue. He married Catherine Bott from Youngstown, Ohio on April 25th 1947. They had two daughters, Janice C and Judy C, and one son Jay C. Dad had one brother, Carson, and one sister, Margaret. Carson had polio and never married. He passed away in 1946. Margaret married William Roemer and lived on Robbins Avenue near the Presbyterian church. Pete was in the Army during WWII serving as an MP in France and England.

Mom worked as a nurse at Northside Hospital until 1962 when Niles City Schools hired her as school nurse where she worked until 1986. After she retired, Mom and Dad moved to Florida where they enjoyed riding their bikes and walking along the trail bordering the nature preserve behind their townhouse. Dad passed away in August 2006 and is buried in Arlington National Cemetery. Mom is still very much alive and in great mental shape today at 100 years old. Editor: Catherine McMurray passed in late 2020 after reaching 100 years of age.

I believe the store was built in 1946 by Dad from his father’s garage. Carrie McMurray, my dad’s aunt, worked at the store some, as did John Roemer. Dad’s two employees were Hilda Nixon and Edna Sexton. Through the years all of us worked some at the store and to a lesser degree I did also but I was only 12 or 13 when the store was sold in 1968.

The store was a dairy delicatessen and had everything a neighborhood store would have back then from magazines to cigarettes, beer, fresh milk products, and fresh eggs that he would get from a lady on a farm past 422 on 46. In the early days the store had a lunch counter where he served ice cream and more, in later years that was done away with. The store was known for its penny candy by all the local kids. The business ran as a cash business with a tab kept for local return customers.”

The reward for helping your Mom was when she gave you a quarter for bread and you got to spend the change on penny candy. Michele Bloom recalls, “Loved Pete’s Dairy, back in the day I grew up on Lincoln and Pete moved in across the street from us. The McMurrays were such nice people. I loved walking down the alley behind our house, it led directly to Pete’s. The penny candy counter was so intriguing, Tootsie Rolls, Mary Jane’s, Double Bubble Gum, so many choices. We loved the ‘pop’ bottles in the cooler chest and the miniature wax ones at the candy counter. We would often buy ‘rolls of caps’and set them off with stones. Ah, the good old days!”

To bolster your bankroll, you searched for discarded glass pop bottles in your neighborhood; the small bottles were worth two cents and the large glass quart bottles earned you a nickel. By far the best memory from the hot summer days was the pop chest with its ice cold water circulating around the glass bottles hiding a multitude of flavors awaiting your hot hands and arms. There was more than Coca-Cola in this treasure chest: Golden Age, Nehi, Seven-Up, Hires Root beer were the bottlers that produced, Orange, Strawberry, Cherry, Black Cherry, and Grape sodas as well as some exotic flavors like Grapefruit and Chocolate pop.

A variety of fudgesicles, ice cream drumsticks encrusted with nuts on the top, creamsicles, and popsicles were available if you dared the freezing cold of the top lidded freezer as you searched quickly before your arm turned cold. A favorite popsicle was the red apple flavor which was guaranteed to turn your tongue and lips the brightest red possible.

Dennis Quilty said, “When I think of Pete’s Dairy I think of all the great candy and bags and bags of beans for my bean shooter.”
It was a safer era in the 50s and 60s when you could walk from your house to the store without your mom worrying that something would happen to you.

— Memories: Ralph Tolbert

Pete McMurray was more than just a store-owner, he supported various Niles' events and ran for public office. Niles was not just a workplace, it was his family's home.


sample advertisements

Pete's Dairy Matchbook

Pete's Dairy Matchbook Cover

ete's Dairy supports PTA

Pete's Dairy Matchbook

Pete's Dairy Matchbook Back

Pete McMurray is second ward candidate

  Copyright©2008-2024, Niles Historical Society, All rights reserved
  Back to top